Best Pizza in South Beach Miami (Updated Fall 2023) - Pizza Oven Radar (2024)

I’ve sampled the wares of 12 local pizza places and I can confidently say that the best pizza in South Beach is not to be missed.

My taste buds have been treated to a variety of styles, from the unique thin-crust offerings to more traditional Neapolitan-style pies. After much debate and analysis over each slice, I’m ready with my officious opinions on who does it best.

Prepare for your taste buds to be tantalized as I share my findings in this review of the best pizza in South Beach Miami.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Pizza Tua

I was thoroughly impressed with the quality of the food they serve and could not recommend them more highly. The crust was light and airy, yet still full-flavored. The cheese was gooey and delicious, complemented by a variety of other toppings that brought out the best in the pizza.

The service was also top notch. The staff were friendly, efficient, and made sure that I had all I needed for a meal to remember.

I have to admit, when I walked into Pizza Tua I wasn’t sure what to expect. But after my experience there, I can honestly say it’s some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! If you’re looking for deliciously crafted pizza in South Beach – this is your spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Miami!

#2 Bitcoin Pizza – South Beach

The moment I stepped through the door, I could tell this was a special place. The aroma of freshly cooked pizza filled the air and made me even more excited to try some of this highly sought after pizza.

The first dish that caught my eye was the ‘Mock-Chain’, which is a half-pepperoni and half-cheese pizza. It was served with a side of garlic butter, topped with onion slices and tasted absolutely delicious – it had the perfect balance of flavors that blended together perfectly.

Next, I sampled the ‘Bit’ pizza, which was loaded up with pepperoni and sausage. This one really put Bitcoin Pizza on the map, as it was just bursting with flavor! The pepperoni was nicely crisp and the sausage was juicy and flavorful – it truly rivaled some of the best pizzas I’ve ever had from around the world!

Finally, I got to try their signature dish – ‘The Satoshi’. This one comes loaded with bacon chunks, mushroom slices, diced tomatoes and cheese – oh boy! It definitely earns its name too as it’s likely to give you quite the ‘Satoshi’ if you’re not careful! However its oozing deliciousness easily make up for its monstrous size – each bite just melted in my mouth.

Overall, my experience at Bitcoin Pizza – South Beach has definitely solidified its spot as one of South Beach’s best pizza restaurants. If you’re looking for great tasting pizza without having to travel too far then this is definitely a great choice!

#3 Limoncello Miami

This restaurant make their pizza dough from scratch and you can really taste the difference. It’s light, fluffy and crunchy – everything a good pizza should be. The sauce is simply amazing too! It’s full of flavor and just the right amount of sweetness.

The toppings they use are always fresh, with a nice combination of cheeses that melts perfectly. Their specialty pizzas are something else too – the creative combinations give the perfect balance between classic flavors and modern tastes.

The atmosphere at Limoncello Miami is great for winding down after a long day with friends or family. They have an open kitchen so you can see how your pizza is prepared and get to know their friendly staff in an intimate setting. Plus, they offer some delicious desserts!

All in all, I would definitely recommend Limoncello Miami for anyone looking for the best pizza in South Beach – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Pummarola Miami Beach “Pizza Napoletana”

I was immediately impressed when I stepped into the restaurant, as the stone-baked oven and fragrant smells of pizza dough filled the air – it was obvious they take great care in bringing traditional Italian pizzas to life.

The service from the staff was friendly and helpful, and before I knew it my individual-sized Neapolitan pizza had arrived. The thin crust made for a light and flavorful experience, with delicious tomato sauce and just the right amount of toppings.

What’s more, Pummarola Miami Beach also offers gluten-free options for those that require them.

All in all, Pummarola Miami Beach is the perfect place for a pizza lover such as me to indulge in some truly mouthwatering treats!

#5 P.Pole Pizza

I had heard a lot about this place before my visit and I must say it did not disappoint. I tried a classic pepperoni pizza, as well as some of their other creative toppings like chipotle-tikka chicken and roasted garlic. The crust was just the right thickness and lightness to be able to handle both these unique flavors without getting soggy or too thick.

The ingredients were all fresh and flavorful, which made me appreciate the thoughtfulness that went into creating each one of these pizzas. The service was also great – they were attentive while taking my order and made sure everything was delivered quickly and spick-and-span!

To top it all off, P.Pole Pizza has an amazing atmosphere with a Miami beach feel to it. The decor is fun with bright colors and interesting artwork; it definitely makes for a great pizza experience!
All in all, P.Pole Pizza is definitely worth the trip if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in South Beach Miami!

#6 Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza

From the moment I walked through the door, the friendly atmosphere and wonderful aromas of freshly-baked pizzas made me feel right at home.

The pizza itself was, in a word, extraordinary. All of the ingredients simply melted together in my mouth and created an unforgettable flavor combination. The crust was perfectly cooked and had a lovely crunch to it, while still being light and airy.

I was particularly pleased with their unique ‘Extra 1’ topping – essentially a layer of garlic butter that added an unexpected level of flavor to an already excellent pizza.

Not only is the pizza delicious, but they also offer vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options as well as a range of homemade sauces to customize your dish.

Overall, I would highly recommend Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza as they have not only some of the best pizzas in South Beach but also offer great customization options to suit everyone’s tastes.

#7 Editor Pizza

I’m sure everyone enjoys a good pizza, and Editor Pizza definitely delivers. The crust was perfectly crisp, the sauce was delightfully tangy, and the toppings were generously plentiful.

The atmosphere at Editor Pizza is great too. It’s cozy but inviting, with plenty of seating to accommodate big groups and couples alike. Plus, they’ve got a decent selection of beer and wine to choose from — perfect for pairing your pizza!

What really sets Editor Pizza apart though is their commitment to freshness and quality ingredients. You can taste it in every bite!

Overall, I’d say Editor Pizza is a must-try if you’re looking for the best pizza in South Beach. As an experienced food critic, I highly recommend adding this spot to your list!

#8 PizzElla – Timeout Market

When I arrived, I was immediately drawn in by the atmosphere. It has a casual yet upscale vibe that is perfect for grabbing a quick slice or having a nice dinner with friends. From the cozy seating arrangements to the mouth-watering aroma of freshly cooked dough, everything about this restaurant just screamed deliciousness.

The menu had all sorts of interesting pizza combinations that looked way too tempting to resist. I went for the classic margherita and was instantly in pizza heaven! The crust was light and fluffy, the tomato sauce rich and flavorful, and the cheese melted to perfection. I’m still drooling thinking about it!

The staff were also amazing; they made sure I was well taken care of throughout my visit and even chatted with me about where I’d been on my travels while they put together my pizza. It really added to the overall experience and made me feel like a VIP customer!

In conclusion, PizzElla – Timeout Market is definitely one of the best places to get pizza in South Beach – hands down!

#9 La Leggenda Pizzeria

The first thing that stood out to me when I walked into the restaurant was how cozy and inviting it felt. The music playing in the background added a nice atmosphere, and all of the staff were friendly and welcoming.

When it comes to pizza, La Leggenda doesn’t disappoint. Their Sicilian pies are truly something special – thick crust, flavorful sauce, generous portions of cheese, and top-quality ingredients. The plain cheese slices are also a must-try!

One of the things I love most about this place is the variety they offer. You can have your pizza any way you like – thin crust or thick crust, extra cheese or no cheese, veggie toppings or meaty toppings – all cooked to perfection!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in South Beach, look no further than La Leggenda Pizzeria. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or looking to try something new, this is definitely one pizza joint that lives up to its name!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Miami!

#10 Buon Pane Italiano Bakery

The moment you walk in, you can smell the fresh baked crust and all the authentic Italian ingredients. The staff is so friendly, and their knowledge of the pizzas and toppings is top-notch!

The pies here are huge – quite literally. I tried the Meat Specialty pizza, which was piled with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, and even more delicious meats. It’s not for the faint of heart (or stomach), but it was worth every bite!

The cheese was perfectly melted onto each slice and had a hint of garlic to add some zest to it. The sauce was perfectly seasoned as well. And did I mention how big these slices were? You’ll definitely have leftovers to take home or eat on your way out.

Overall, Buon Pane Italiano Bakery is a real gem in South Beach when it comes to pizza. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza around, definitely give them a try!

#11 Grafa Pizza

The pizza here is cooked in a wood-fire oven, and the crust has just the right crispiness to it. The toppings are always fresh, and their blend of cheese is perfectly balanced.

No matter what type of pizza I’ve ordered at Grafa Pizza – from classic Margherita to something more creative like their Garden of Eden – it’s been one delicious slice after another.

Speaking of delicious slices, don’t forget about the garlic knots! They’re mind-blowing with their savory garlic butter and light crunchy texture.

I was also pleasantly surprised by the friendly atmosphere at Grafa Pizza. The staff make sure you’re happy with your order, and they even chat with you if you want to chat. It’s really comforting after a long day on the road!

Grafa Pizza gets two enthusiastic thumbs up from me – they have some of the best pizza in South Beach!

#12 Blocks Pizza

On my first visit, I was greeted by a friendly team, eager to get me on my way with a delicious bite. The atmosphere of the place was inviting and relaxing, perfect for taking some time out of your day to be enjoyed with family and friends.

As soon as I took a bite of their signature pizza, I knew I’d hit the jackpot! A thin and crispy crust topped with the perfect combination of savory, cheesy flavors that had me coming back again and again. Not only that, but their topping selection is so vast and creative you won’t know what to order next – from traditional ingredients like pepperoni to more unique ones like pineapple. Whatever you pick will satisfy your craving in every way possible!

In conclusion, Blocks Pizza is definitely worth visiting if you’re looking for great pizza in South Beach – it’s sure to exceed all your expectations!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Pizza Rustica South Beach

Now, let’s talk about the benefits. Firstly, the fact that Pizza Rustica serves alcohol deserves a round of applause. Who doesn’t love an ice-cold beer with their cheesy pizza goodness? Plus, they offer some vegetarian options, so you can bring your herbivore buddies along without any worries. And did I mention they have dessert? Because nothing brings me more joy than ending a pizza feast with a sweet treat.

Speaking of joy, Pizza Rustica South Beach is also a nice tourist spot. You can people-watch and pretend you’re in an Italian piazza while chomping down on your heavenly thin crust creation. It truly adds a touch of class to your pizza-eating experience. You might even catch me there, penning my next food critique!

Now, let’s address the downside – they don’t accept reservations. So, if you’re a control freak like me who loves to plan every second of their life, leave your spreadsheet at home. Just take the leap of faith and trust that you’ll find a table. It might be a little chaotic, but hey, sometimes the best things in life are unexpected, just like stumbling upon the best thin crust pizza in South Beach!

In conclusion, Pizza Rustica South Beach is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. Their thin crust will make your taste buds do a happy dance while the lively atmosphere and adult beverages will make your night unforgettable. So, grab your friends, keep your cool, and let the cheesy adventure begin!